pierfishing.com :: FAQ :: search :: memberlist :: album
  Sign-up as new user :: log in



Sign-up as new user | I forgot my password

PFIC Message Boards >> Pier and Surf Fishing Reply to this topic
>> huntin for dinos... tips? [topic: previous/next]
PostPosted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 7:26 pm
calaznfisher


Posts: 580

ok, my goal, before the end of this year, is to catch a sturgeon from the shore, or pier. ive been doing as much research as i can, because i have never really been dino hunting before, but i want to see if any of the veterans here have any tips to offer. i know its mostly a sit and wait game, but i want to make sure i am waiting in the right area.

from everything that i have learned, the sturgeon should be starting to make their migration up into the delta soon/now. this would then seem like the prime time to intercept them on their way up. however, i have also read that only parts of the population will spawn every year, and that the remainder will stay in the more salty bay areas. thus, i am going to assume that fishing a transition area such as the carquinez strait or suisun bay will most likely increase the chances of hooking into one. if anyone has any good spots that may yield good shore fishing results for me, or any advice in finding a good spot, please let me know.

i will probably be using ghost or grass shrimp on a traditional sturgeon leader with 2 hooks on 60 lb nylon coated wire.

i have not seen any good tips on hooking grass shrimp for sturgeon, so i assume just hooking a number of them by the tail so that the hook is covered with kicking shrimp, should suffice?

i have also heard that a strong outgoing will muddy up the substrate and increase sturgeon activity, but will this hold true up past the strait? i have also heard the the end of the outgoing will probably hold the most action, but it appears that this information is mostly gathered from boat fishermen, which may not apply to us shore fishermen.

lastly, i have heard of the famous "sturgeon pump" but it is not clear to me when to strike? does the sturgeon pump preclude the sturgeon from inhaling the bait and swimming off which then necessitates a strike, or does the strike have to occur precisely in the middle of a pump?

anyways, these are my thought for now, please let me know if there is any information you all might think would help me on my search for a dino... i am a strict catch and release fisher, and i will not spot burn so feel free to PM me if privacy is an issue.

thanks!!!
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 10:06 pm
mel


Posts: 2224

If you manage to get one by December, congratulations! Most need years to accomplish that. The sturgies are on the move but they should be coming down from the delta, not heading up. Carquinez and Suisun Straits are good prospects year round. Don't forget to try eel and roe fishing that area. If you use grass shrimp, use miracle thread to hold them on. Good luck finding folks willing to give up their spot, especially if it's a good one. Don't depend on a certain tide to produce fish. Fish the whole tide. Put in your time. And forget about the "sturgeon pump". You have more chances of getting "pumped" from a boat but it's usually a different bite from the shoreline or pier. Hard to explain but don't wait for a pump. By the time it "pumps" and your fishing from shore your fish is most likely gone. Set the hook on everything and set it hard. Lastly, just put some bait on your line cast it out there. The heck with details. Keep it simple. Use the search feature of the board and you'll most likely find answers to all of your questions. No PM necessary. I won't tell you in a PM what I won't tell you here. Good luck on your adventure! And don't forget, most of all, put in your time. The more time spent on the water the more chances you'll have of hooking up. Watch the regulars, talk to the OG's and get what you can from them if they are willing to give it up. Watch what they do and look at what they're using. Bait AND tackle.
_________________
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 10:41 pm
red fish


Posts: 1813
Location: Berkeley Pier

Quote:

Subject: huntin for dinos... tips?

ok, my goal, before the end of this year, is to catch a sturgeon from the shore, or pier. ive been doing as much research as i can, because i have never really been dino hunting before...
Okay, that is a lofty goal, but possible..I assume you mean a keeper sturge..



Quote:

i know its mostly a sit and wait game, but i want to make sure i am waiting in the right area.
Any of the sturgeon areas from Ken's list will produce; the thing you want to do is pick a couple and figure out how to fish them. http://www.pierfishing.com/resources/index.php?id=fish:white_sturgeon

Quote:
from everything that i have learned, the sturgeon should be starting to make their migration up into the delta soon/now. this would then seem like the prime time to intercept them on their way up. however, i have also read that only parts of the population will spawn every year, and that the remainder will stay in the more salty bay areas. thus, i am going to assume that fishing a transition area such as the carquinez strait or suisun bay will most likely increase the chances of hooking into one.
This is a fair assumption, but not a rock solid rule for a shoreliner. You are trying to get the same fish the boaters are going after; difference is, you are shorebound, other than picking up and driving another locale. Follow the reports the boaters use as well, as you will more than likely be fishing in the same area, although under the confinement of the land.


Quote:
if anyone has any good spots that may yield good shore fishing results for me, or any advice in finding a good spot, please let me know.
A good spot is relevant to shore/pier fishing, as, a good spot from shore could be considered (1) keeper being caught a day, whereas, some will call (2) caught a day for an entire pier a great spot.

Quote:
i will probably be using ghost or grass shrimp on a traditional sturgeon leader with 2 hooks on 60 lb nylon coated wire.
Either of those baits are top baits, and, any way they stay on the hook will work. Any sturgeon rig will work; the main thing is that it holds the bottom; a rig that planes up off the bottom does not get bit, so adjust the weight accordingly and add weight near the hook (note different rules apply in terms of leader length east of 680/hwy 4). Holding bottom is critical to detecting a bite, especially in the Carquinez Strait and other rough ares with 12-60 feet of water and fast moving current (a spider-sinker is recommended where an 8oz pyramid is acceptable. If you can find a shallow area of 6-15' of water to fish sturgeon, you can get away with 4 to 6oz of weight easy and sometimes just a plain old surf-leader depending on the area.

[quote]i have not seen any good tips on hooking grass shrimp for sturgeon, so i assume just hooking a number of them by the tail so that the hook is covered with kicking shrimp, should suffice?[/hook] Hell, just hooking three good-sized grass shrimp on after the other string them on a single kahle hook has worked for general sturgeon fishing for me and Joey Pallota.

Quote:
i have also heard that a strong outgoing will muddy up the substrate and increase sturgeon activity, but will this hold true up past the strait? i have also heard the the end of the outgoing will probably hold the most action, but it appears that this information is mostly gathered from boat fishermen, which may not apply to us shore fishermen.
Location, location, location..as Brian would say... I found that incoming tide has been the best at a lot of spots I have had success in..especially along the Carquinez Straits. Incoming right before it tops out, but before it swings out... The out-going is treacherous on the straits, and, really, a lot of people pack it in and go home on the swift moving outgo because they can no longer hold bottom. Not impossible, but not the best time to fish. Other spots, such as some points that still have enough water to fish at low-tide can be good on outgoing.

Quote:
lastly, i have heard of the famous "sturgeon pump" but it is not clear to me when to strike? does the sturgeon pump preclude the sturgeon from inhaling the bait and swimming off which then necessitates a strike, or does the strike have to occur precisely in the middle of a pump?
When in doubt, swing for the fences.. the very first sturgeon I caught at night at Point Molate, I didn't even know I had it on, but I used to make a practice of setting my hook when I would reel in to check bait (just encase something is sitting on the line). Usually, on the third pump, if you can get to the rod by then (and if you can, set while it is pumping down instead of back (or up). If you see six pumps, you are getting late in the game.. There is also the bite that looks like a small striper, bullhead, kingfish, and the suicide bite where it just takes off and rips line.

IF there is a herring spawn that you can catch, and you can time it just right, that can be more of win/win situation if you can get there and have space. Again, follow what the people with radar are doing and where they are going.. Places like the Oakland Airport and the Sturgeon Triangle can all produce fish - timing>right tide>and few hours spent. There have been a couple times where I have come up and left with a keeper all within one-hour's time... I can't help but think the reward came from all the countless hours of nada and just hopeful ambition... good luck...tight lines, sharp hooks, fish on and all that....
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 11:21 pm
calaznfisher


Posts: 580

WOW redfish and mel thanks a BUNCH for the fast and thorough replies...

i actually did not think that catching my first dino by the end of this year was too lofty a goal LOL... i was thinking that maybe 80 hours of fishing would maybe yield one? i guess we'll see, but i hope this doesn't end up a mission impossible! =P

im not looking for a keeper sturgie, just any sturgie so i can have a picture of it in my fish album... a nice big one would be great though!

a few more questions - is live bait MUCH better than frozen (ghost, grass, eel)? which side of the strait tends to have better fishing? ive seen sturgeon rigs with one, two, and three hooks... any reason why any of these would work better than the others?

thanks again!!
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Sun Oct 25, 2009 11:51 pm
FishermanDan


Posts: 2495

I caught my first and only sturgeon on the 7th consecutive day fishing McNears Beach Pier. Classic "pump", three times(kinda like a slow, hard dip in your pole). The bait was inside-out anchovies, on a high low, top hook. Set the hook on the fourth pump, it made a short run, then came to the surface and jumped twice. I was the onnly one on the pier, and had to walk it all the way to the base(didn't mond that walk at all). Although I did learn that its important to bring a net, in case you are alone. I caught my fish in May.

The best advise has already been given. Put your time in. At the right place. Go where you know other people have caught them(such as McNears pier in my case), and fish until your time arrives.
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 6:59 am
illcatchanything2


Posts: 4398

Your goal is not impossible, but it is lofty Smile

Some people take years to get a legal. Like everyone else said, time and patience.

As far as good spots, anywhere along the straights, the Rodeo Shoreline, Pinole Shoreline, and later on, Richmond, Berkeley, Emeryville. If you dont get one by Dec., Keep trying, also dont forget that Sturgeon is closed in the "Triangle" formed by the 3 bridges in the SF bay from Jan to March. In the spring (after the closure) Emeryville at the end of Powell street behind the restaurant is a good bet.

As for bait, live ghost/grass shrimp or a combo of the 2 are a good bet. Salmon roe is a great bait, its one drawback is that the sharks love it as well. I have tried eel, but have never had any luck with it. If you are fishing in an area where Herring are spawning, then of course you will want to try Herring as well.

Also, keep an eye out on the event board, as I will be hosting a Christmas "Dino Hunt" get together in December. Location has not been set yet, but will depend on a number of factors.

One last thing, dont be too hard on yourself if you dont meet your goal. I fish hard for them every season, but have not gotten a legal from Shore/Pier since 07.

_________________
Fish like this is your last day on earth, conserve like you will live 1000 years.
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 7:30 am
vitanksi


Posts: 179
Location: Vallejo

20 years of fishing (ha) and I've only caught 1 sturgeon, and that was last year. It was barely legal, but I didn't have a sturgeon card so I tossed it back. I was fishing from the shore in Benicia, targeting stripers with a hi-lo with cut anchovies. It was a slack, low tide, and a little muddy. I thought some seaweed had snagged my line and I started reeling in. The thing didn't even fight, run, or attempt to swim away. It was like reeling in a log.

I have zero luck fishing. I basically do it to pass the time, and keep myself out of trouble. If I can do it, anybody can. Smile

Good luck!
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 1:41 pm
FishermanDan


Posts: 2495

Although the "triangle" formed by the 3 main bridges in the SF bay is indeed closed, the "sturgeon triangle" is actually something different, and is a great place to legally target them(hint: even from shore). The Sturgeon Triangle is formed by locations: The Pumphouse, China Camp, and Buoy 5. These are are places usually talked about by boaters, although there is good shore access to the area around the southern tip of the Triangle(China Camp), which is well worth fishing.
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 1:44 pm
FishermanDan


Posts: 2495

This is why McNears Beach Pier was a great destination for sturgeon anglers, and why many sturgeon have been caught there. There are many guys who are anxiously waiting for the repairs to be done so the pier can be reopened.
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 5:38 pm
dkkim


Posts: 802

If your fishing rod tip even looks quirky set the hook. If the wind blows and makes your rod tip jiggle... set the hook. You can't really wait for a typical sturgeon pump. Also, I don't think anyone mentioned but make sure you don't get your scent on the bait. If you smoke, make sure you put some of that stinky stuff on your bait.
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 8:49 pm
iamfisherman


Posts: 2203
Location: NorCal...

I don't know if it works here since it saltwater but my buddies in Oregon fish with large night crawlers along with there bait of crappie or perch fillets w/ skin on in the columbia, it might be illegal here to use crappie or perch fillets though and the salt might kill the night crawler pretty quick.
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Mon Oct 26, 2009 9:04 pm
FishermanDan


Posts: 2495

You can pump your own ghost shrimp at the Alameda Rock Wall. Good spot to get sturgeon too, right at the 1st bend. Thats all you need.
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Tue Oct 27, 2009 6:19 am
illcatchanything2


Posts: 4398

iamfisherman wrote:
I don't know if it works here since it saltwater but my buddies in Oregon fish with large night crawlers along with there bait of crappie or perch fillets w/ skin on in the columbia, it might be illegal here to use crappie or perch fillets though and the salt might kill the night crawler pretty quick.


It would not be illegal to use the perch as long as they were legally taken and perch is open at the time when you are fishing. Dont know about crappie. Night crawlers tend to dissolve in the salt, but sturgeon will hit pile worms. That would be a good alternative.

_________________
Fish like this is your last day on earth, conserve like you will live 1000 years.
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 4:53 pm
calaznfisher


Posts: 580

a bit off topic, but i found this picture while researching sturgeon fishing, and thought it was pretty cool... want to find high concentrations of sturgeon? follow channels that the sturgeon can follow out from the shallow mudflats that they feed in during the high tides...



look at the guy on the right with a fishing pole. LOL!

mcnears sounds like a perfect pier to target sturgeon from, but... well, you know.

fishermandan - how many hours did you fish each day you were there? were you specifically targeting sturgeon? how big was it?
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PostPosted: Wed Oct 28, 2009 5:29 pm
marty gingras


Posts: 106

ftp://ftp.delta.dfg.ca.gov/Adult_Sturgeon_and_Striped_Bass/2008%20Sturgeon%20Card%20Complete%20Draft%20Version%201.pdf
Top of page
Send private message Make a quoted reply on this post
PFIC Message Boards >> Pier and Surf Fishing Reply to this topic
Page 1 of 1  
Display posts from previous:   
Jump to: